Do "Name Your Price" games count as commercial?

TheNothingMonster

Creepy Thing
Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2022
Messages
10
Reaction score
3
First Language
Greek
Primarily Uses
RMVXA
Some publishing sites I have come across allow the uploader to either set their games as free, paid, or let the audience choose whatever price they want to pay (AKA: Name Your Price).

Knowing that there is the option to download a project for free in the latter cases, are these projects commercial, non-commercial or something in-between? For instance, if someone uses non-commercial-only materials or scripts, will it be fair to set the game's price as “Name Your Price” or is it advised to release it for free?

I reckon the second option, but I want to be completely sure.
 

Finnuval

Old Raven following Rainbows
Regular
Joined
Aug 1, 2018
Messages
2,731
Reaction score
10,349
First Language
Dutch
Primarily Uses
RMMZ
As @ATT_Turan says and to specify a little further : it's not wether or not you actually make money of it but rather if you potentially COULD make money of it that makes it commercial.
 

Andar

Regular
Regular
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
39,892
Reaction score
11,851
First Language
German
Primarily Uses
RMMV
And as a third aspect - you're asking from the wrong direction.

What really counts is not your definition of commercial use, but the (licence source) definition of commercial use.

You are obviously asking because you have some resources with a licence "free only for non-commercial" or the like - otherwise you wouldn't bother to ask.
In all such cases what counts is the definition of the artist for whatever has that "only non-commercial" licence.
If said artist says that a single donation button on a free download site for the game counts as "commercial use", then THAT definition counts and not whatever someone else said.
And yes, that was a specific and real example of a programmer who is no longer active in the community but made that definition for the use of his scripts at the time of VXA.

So if you really want to be sure, then you would have to contact every artist of the resources you use that give such a licence to ask them if they consider that commercial use or not.
 

lianderson

Regular
Regular
Joined
Dec 27, 2012
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,297
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
N/A
I don't think it should be, but it don't matter what I think. It matters what the artist and law thinks.
 

Andar

Regular
Regular
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
39,892
Reaction score
11,851
First Language
German
Primarily Uses
RMMV
law thinks.
no, because the law has no opinion on this.

Copyright Law is civil law - which means it does absolutely nothing until the copyright holder (the artist) tells someone "this is a violation and I want to sue them".

That is why so many violations stay on the internet for a long time - the copyright holder needs to know of something and where it is before he/she could initiate the process of takedown.
And absolutely no one else can initiate that takedown, all everyone else could do is contact the copyright holder and inform them.
 

gstv87

Regular
Regular
Joined
Oct 20, 2015
Messages
3,361
Reaction score
2,553
First Language
Spanish
Primarily Uses
RMVXA
there needs to be established that the price the people is paying is directly connected with the use of those assets that were deemed not-for-commercial-use.
if the game can be downloaded for free regardless, then there's no direct link between the payment and the acquisition of that game.
an action that itself can be prosecuted for violations of various OTHER laws, but that's up to the relevant authorities.

if the terms of use of the assets you get state "exclusively for non-commercial use", you better get a clarification from the author stating that "you're authorized for this exception".... otherwise they can claim commercial use under the scope of [you running a business off the trade of making games, regardless of profit] instead of [you making a profit for the sell of this specific product, regardless of business model]

as times go, you need to speak at least five languages: your native language, a lingua franca, and also Engineer, Lawyer and Doctor, just in case.
 

Latest Profile Posts

I have completed what is clearly the most important part of participating in the game jam: coming up with a name!
My shrink has me trying to limit 30 mins a day for each of my personal projects so I can have a healthier life. But lately the rpg making in particular has been hard to pull away from and I keep getting lost in it.
Everyone has a test project named like this...right?

1701263020760.png
Pardon my japanese but this is my honest reaction to yesterday's "tangent":
1701262223568.png
I know these are all simple things for experienced users, but working on this Game Jam I have officially learned how to:
  • Use my own title screen image
  • Use scrolling text
  • Fade in a picture
  • Use any image for the Face in a dialog box
Probably silly for many people, but observable progress for me!

Forum statistics

Threads
136,570
Messages
1,267,661
Members
180,251
Latest member
SolarPH
Top