(Personal opinions only, and won't try to spoil any bits)
I liked FF1 for the NES alot.
I could not get int II
I never played III if I remember correctly.
I played IV I think it was 2 in the US. I beat it but to be honest, I think it kind of sucked a bit. Like, sure great length for the cash money but it sucked toward the middle and just never recovered for me.
I played a rom translation of V, the job system was fascinating for me. I liked some of the base bonuses you got for mastering a job that were like passive abilities for your character while you were whatever other job, overall, thought the game was boring. I didn't really like the music, didn't 'hate' the main villain, didn't feel attached to anyone, some mechanics were good though.
I played VI, and am probably gonna say this one was my favorite. The right mix of weird stuff that makes no sense but it's there, and good music. Loved the Esper system, and the level up bonuses you could pass around via the Espers.
I got VII for Christmas one year, and played it. Loved it for what it was. I didn't like the pacing of the story as much, and being stuck in Midgard as long. Really not a fan of the cussing just cause it makes it real aspect of the dialogue. I REALLY did not like Cloud. Didn't like his name, didn't like him, didn't like Barret either. Vincent was ok. Big fan of Tifa, but wish it had more focus on her martial arts instructor. Materia system was like a stupidly bamboozled version of the Esper system. Wish they just kept espers. Have no idea what made Sephiroth so popular. Thought he was kind of stupid, and should have just died and that should have been the end of him. Really, Felt VI was MUCH better game. (I'd elaborate but I don't want to spoil it for people who haven't played it). Really though, VII was pretty good, worth a play through if you're interested in modern JRPG's and want to see how and where and why alot of the elements of rpg games gets it from. Was it worth all the praise and adulation? No. Absolutely not.
FFVIII if you want really contrived weirdness. Actually may be one of the few people that liked the Draw and Junction system.. I wouldn't not have had the spells be expendable items but maybe if it just had to be that way, maybe make it an elemental energy gauge and you are draining the elemental energy from um.. fish.. and behemoths. Yeah, leave me alone
@EpicFILE . I like fish.
FFIX Really didn't not view this as a game that had nostalgia in mind. It was my least favorite of the series up until that point. I DID like Vivi, and some of the music. Kuja probably one of the most ridiculous enemies of the game.. then there is the actual, well don't let me spoil it.
FFX Meg Ryan in aquatic sports games. I like that they tried to get rid of being level 15 or whatever level. I kind of fill the sphere grid could be a re-inventing of the wheel, in a good way. A spherical way.. haha. Yes, I'm not sure the sphere grid was well implemented, it might almost would have been better if there were different grids that people could access. Like Auron doesn't get the same sphere that Lulu gets maybe. Aside from that, really liked alot to do with X. I though Seymour was pretty stupid, maybe the stupidest of all of Final Fantasy ever. That is saying alot.
Meg Ryan was not liked either.
FFXI I played this game ALOT. I mean, way more than I played the others, but it was online only. I really felt the older final fantasy xi was better than newer final fantasy xi. Why? I dunno. I like being punished for playing games maybe. I dunno. Meow.
FFXII I really didn't like this game. Apparently a lot of people didn't but, it greatly exceeds not liking Vaan, or Penelo, or Ashe or whoever else. It was just a big overly cinematic game. I didn't like the version of Cid, or the political 'intrigue' aspect they tried to put into it. I liked the overworld aspects, and the way combat was handled. But there was just a yawn factor I can't put my paws on. Meow. I kind of lost faith in Final Fantasy after playing XII. The designs of the characters etc. The judges maybe were the 'coolest' part of the game. I am not a fan of thonged bunny women. Lots going on in this game that made me not like it. Bad voice acting. Bad setting, boring story. Etc. Razzler. King Razzler. Ok, yeah I'll quit the nagging.
FFXIII Ok, I had said IX was my least favorite up until that point. This one takes the whole bakery, no.. the grocery store. Forget the cake. It didn't even bake one, it burnt it.. killed everybody that had anything to do with baking it. Sadly, this game somehow was called good by masses of people. How? You don't even get to choose anything. You can't stop at a town, the crafting sucks, there's really no side plots, just side missions, the main villain is so dumb it actually blew my mind this was even a game Square put out. Really, this game defied the boundaries of massive flops in my opinion. How? Even IX was fun in comparison. Leveling up? Hold the button down to spend your points. You can't choose, except to skip a stat bonus. No point really. It's boring, it even keeps your from leveling up, which is in my opinion WORSE than level scaling to keep monsters relevant. It was just a horrible game, and some how the white knight crowd defended it.. I am almost certain they had hired goons troll people that had legitimate arguments about why they disliked the game. That sounds ridiculous, but this has been proven time and again on so many other issues, it wouldn't surprise me in the least way if it turned out agenda driven farts had infiltrated the game market and used this tactic.
FFXIV I played this a little bit. Really I didn't like WoW, and this is basically WoW with better graphics. The lead designer literally told his group play WoW, and take the elements from that game and put in "our game". The original version of the game supposedly sucked so hard they almost had to take it offline, they did remake it under the new lead designer guy. If given a choice I'd rather play XIV than WoW. But I don't play that stuff no mo. Meow.
Square really has made a lot of bad choices, the books show it. BUT, they are willing to take the risks, and they get the pay off occasionally. I just wish they'd go back to the basics maybe. If you take the NES FF1 and just updated the graphics and sound, it'd laughed out of the market place. I get kind of hopeful though, thinking about RPG Maker. Maybe I can send them a game and they'll kick me in the kitty legs and tell me to shut up.