good roadblocks

Discussion in 'Game Mechanics Design' started by Oddball, Jun 22, 2016.

  1. Wavelength

    Wavelength Pre-Merge Boot Veteran

    Messages:
    3,449
    Likes Received:
    2,621
    Location:
    Florida, USA
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMVXA


    "The Senator and I are in vigorous agreement!" - H. Clinton
     



    I didn't ever mean to imply, in my example of removing the roadblock (by not having the port town / not initially mentioning the Holy Gem at the other side of the ocean), that the player has no strong reason to be doing something.  The player should always have a strong reason to be doing whatever it is they are currently doing.  In fact, this is at the core of my entire philosophy on roadblocks - weakly-justified ones make the player feel like they don't need to be doing what they're asked to do, because there is realistically a much easier and better solution that the game is just ignoring.



    The simple fact that there are no places to explicitly hire a boat and no reason given to think about the need to hire a boat before it's time to do so.  It's the same logic as why FF7 players didn't think about "why can't I leave Midgar" in the first 5 hours of the game.  You didn't come across a checkpoint with a guard that said "you can't leave"; you didn't come across any obvious roadblock.  You didn't hear too much about there being a whole world outside of the city.  You simply did engaging things inside the city, and accepted it as the setting for your story and gameplay.  Then, only when it comes time to leave, you're told to travel to Kalm, and in doing so you get to see that there's this whole world out there to explore that you didn't even know about.


    I think for the most part we agree; I'm totally on board with the idea that an activity's integration into the larger game and especially the narrative are crucial to making that activity feel satisfying.  I'm taking it one step further and saying that the immediacy of a given objective (for objectives like "travel to X", as opposed to obviously large-scope ones like "defeat the evil overlord") also furthers that goal.
     
    #21
  2. Oddball

    Oddball Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    1,176
    Likes Received:
    210
    First Language:
    English
    what about a bridge being out on purpose because someone was mugged on the road ahead and they (thoserepairing it) suggest to explore some ruins while they work?
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 29, 2016
    #22
  3. Wavelength

    Wavelength Pre-Merge Boot Veteran

    Messages:
    3,449
    Likes Received:
    2,621
    Location:
    Florida, USA
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMVXA


    Yeah, I think we were largely doing this :)  Just to be perfectly clear - I don't think that "invisibility" as solution to this roadblock is necessarily absurd; I think it's only absurd when there's an obvious, easier solution from a narrative (not gameplay) point of view, such as asking to be let in or pushing away a single guard.  Or when it requires the kind of "90s adventure game" chain of puzzles that you mentioned.  Looking at you, Sierra.



    I was specifically referring to CRPGs - yes, a lot of CRPG players are used to the strange asks by virtue of old CRPG games, but they can also recognize these strange asks more easily than a neophyte RPGer can.  I know that I for one have become really jaded to this kind of thing, and it feels like such a chore when a CRPG makes a nonsensical ask of me.  I know others that feel the same way, and I feel like the majority do, although I could be wrong.


    And I'm 100% in favor of offering multiple solutions to a problem, whether that's "2 or 3 obvious ways" or "anything and everything the dev team can think of" - it's a huge draw for me when I play any game - but I think that's a gameplay issue that goes far beyond the scope of roadblocks.


    (And P&P can go beyond that, even, because a good Game Master can improvise when the players come up with something he hadn't.  I love P&P roleplaying.)



    This sounds like a pretty good example!  (I think it could be made even more convincing by implying the passage of some time before the player is allowed to enter the tower.)  Thanks for that!
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 29, 2016
    #23
    Anthony Xue likes this.
  4. Anthony Xue

    Anthony Xue Ancient Architect Veteran

    Messages:
    75
    Likes Received:
    87
    Location:
    In the Deep Library
    First Language:
    German
    Glad you liked it. And thanks for the interesting discussion. I'll try to work it into my blog entry, it would be a shame to let all of this drown within the sea of old postings.
     
    #24
    Wavelength likes this.
  5. Prescott

    Prescott riju Veteran

    Messages:
    401
    Likes Received:
    178
    Location:
    USA
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMMV
    Forgive me if I'm just repeating stuff, too lazy to read the thread ;)


    I think the best way to put natural roadblocks in the players way is to actually make it feel natural. When you're watching a horror movie where the protagonist is stuck in a house that has a full on kitchen that probably has a lot of knives they could use against the killer, you ask "why don't they just defend themselves instead of running around and not using their surroundings?" That's kind of how I felt playing Outlast. Miles is in an insane asylum with weapons practically everywhere but spends all of his time running. The roadblocks in that game are a gigantic insane guy randomly appearing and forcing you to run away, or throwing you into a different location of the asylum (he's like a cave-in).


    HOWEVER, if you put the player in an environment or a situation where they can't do something about their roadblock, and it's always been there (like an ocean they need to get a boat to travel across), it feels much more natural.


    We are letting the player go pretty much anywhere right from the get-go in our game. You can take down the big bosses in any order you feel. Anything preventing the player from doing that is a natural barrier. Dark Souls does something a lot where the enemies you encounter will be WAY too hard for you to take on and you pretty much immediately die. I mean, if you're skilled enough, by all means go for it, but there shouldn't be something indirectly telling you "maybe I shouldn't be here right now." Enemies, harsh conditions (maybe they need a bigger coat to go into the cold regions, or something like the earrings in Skyward Sword that enable you to go into a hotter part of the volcano), or somewhere they won't make much progress (like if you were to play Wind Waker without the sail).


    It's important, I think, to let players explore these places even if there are warnings in place that they shouldn't be there. Even if you're focusing on a more linear story, you could always have the player move forward and trigger a different sequence of events if they ACTUALLY made it through that place without dying, or make it impossible to get through without dying so the player knows they have to do something else first.


    I know it's hard to implement all of this as an indie developer, and that it usually takes a much larger studio to account for all of this uncertainty of what a player is going to do, but just look at a game like Undertale. Toby Fox thought of absolutely everything a player could do inside and outside of the game to affect it. It's possible for sure, and your game will be much better, in my opinion, if you let players explore all of these avenues and give them natural consequences to their actions.
     
    #25
  6. HexMozart88

    HexMozart88 The Master of Random Garbage Veteran

    Messages:
    1,567
    Likes Received:
    2,765
    Location:
    A small hut in the forest
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMVXA
    Aw, man. I don't know why I hate this so much, but don't use "It's locked..." It's super cliche and not very creative in my opinion. A good thing to do sometimes (depending on how you do it) is to say, "Such-and-such is calling me. I'd better go see what they want."  (Obviously replace such-and-such with whoever.) Or if you want, you can also do enemies that are like, ten levels higher than you and you have to get to a certain level or a certain point in the game to be able to beat them. 
     
    #26
  7. Tai_MT

    Tai_MT Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    4,916
    Likes Received:
    3,804
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMMV
    I have the "It's locked." Roadblocks.  But, they make sense.  The door to a bandit hideout isn't going to have an unlocked door...  A treasure chest with a lock meant to be picked by a certain character you don't have yet, will be locked.


    But, I do have some in the traditional sense.  The first storyline quest of my game takes place at a house that is locked up until you hit level 2.  The character can check the locked door, talk to the NPC nearby, asking about it being locked and some somewhat spoilery content, and it won't open.  When the door is unlocked, new NPCs appear in the town nearby to ask if you've been in the spooky house at all, and they warn you to stay away from it.


    The other notable examples of the "It's locked" come in the form of "shortcuts" that you need a semi-rare currency called "Silver Key" to open.  Usually, these keys open shortcuts in dungeons/caves, or treasure rooms, or other stuff that a key might apply to.  But, without the key, it tells you "It's locked."
     
    #27
    Marsigne likes this.
  8. HexMozart88

    HexMozart88 The Master of Random Garbage Veteran

    Messages:
    1,567
    Likes Received:
    2,765
    Location:
    A small hut in the forest
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    RMVXA
    Those are decent uses of "It's locked..." but what I was talking about is when half the houses in a village are locked and you can barely go anywhere. The point of rpgs is to explore, I think. So let the player explore or they'll get bored. Also, being locked up until a certain point is okay if it has some use to the game, however, if you have a door that is locked the whole time, why put it down in the first place? Basically what I'm saying is to do as you did and be clever about it, otherwise don't make the door at all.   
     
    #28
    Prescott likes this.
  9. Oddball

    Oddball Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    1,176
    Likes Received:
    210
    First Language:
    English
    Hey ive got a good roadblock! Roadblocks! :p
     
    #29
  10. F117Landers

    F117Landers Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    63
    Likes Received:
    5
    First Language:
    English


    With construction crews!


    On topic, this has been a concern of mine. In the current game I'm working on, I have found a decent reason as to why the player can't wander outside of the maps (he's dead). Every challenge accomplished to continue progress through the veil unlocks more areas (new challenges). This also allows me plausibility for certain items not being interactive. 


    Obviously this doesn't work in most games, but there are many ways to dress up roadblocks so that players don't go "the door is locked, but it is half missing. Why can't I just reach through and unlock it?"
     
    #30
  11. Aurelius

    Aurelius Villager Member

    Messages:
    15
    Likes Received:
    2
    First Language:
    English
    Link the second game on NES had a cave or caves you could try and get through without your candle, but it was usually deadly. This is a good example of a roadblock that is a bit more interesting than just something blocking your way.

    Whirlpools, fallen trees (when your characters are in a cart perhaps), Sandstorms ("block your way ahead") would be cool some particle effects showing a sandstorm, or hail storm or blizzard. So environmental types of blocks.

    A cliff that requires climbing equipment or a grapple. (So like LINK for NES, you need an item to pass) or a vehicle like a boat or raft.

    Chasms.

    Just think of what might block your way in real life. Then there is also magic, so magical barriers.
     
    #31
  12. Manofdusk

    Manofdusk Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    211
    Likes Received:
    37
    First Language:
    English
    You could make certain events timed. If certain disaster is about to befall a nearby city if you don't act, then it WILL happen if your character wanders off to the caves in the opposite direction. It's not exactly a roadblock but it DOES keep players on track. Timers work wonders for this too (nothing says "don't wander off" like a countdown)


     If you need to get across the ocean for some reason but there are powerful sea monsters keeping the boats from going out, that also makes a good roadblock. You could fight it (maybe you CAN actually beat it if you grind a few levels), or you could go do a quest that calms/defeats them. I don't consider something like this to be a roadblock since it's part of the narrative.


     Now, with a locked door... I'm a little on the fence. If it's a fairly sturdy door, then I can get it but if it's not, then just break it down if you really need to get in (I actually like to do this. Have a door that's locked and offer the player the chance to get the key... but, if you keep examining the door, one of the characters gets irritable and breaks it down).


     I also do things like, when in towns, your character can actually get in trouble (ie. get a "go to jail" ending) for entering someone's house uninvited. When the player understands this, he's less likely to be trying to open random doors in towns.


     When a character is given an open world, then it should really be free to explore... but if there are limits in place that the player understands (like in my above example of the player getting in trouble for stealing/trespassing) then certain roadblocks make sense. However, I dislike the excessive use of roadblocks on the story path. Staying on the path of the narrative should be fairly easy. The roadblocks should only be popping up if you're trying to bypass the narrative.


     That said, I do like having ways to bypass the roadblocks guarding the narrative, letting you go places you wouldn't be able to otherwise (ie. Sequence Breaking). The game becomes considerably harder when sequence breaking but you can get access to special items or alternate endings by doing so.


     In the example I gave of fighting the sea monsters. If you kill them, then they drop an ingredient used to make a weapon more powerful than anything you'd get for quite some time (AND you passed the roadblock).
     
    #32
  13. eadgear

    eadgear Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    88
    Likes Received:
    67
    First Language:
    english
    Good roadblock? what about the road itself than blocks you. That's literally roadblock. Imagine the ground changes and/or started to attack you, even the spikes floor and ceiling attacks you. The ground can even chase you.
     
    #33
    Oddball likes this.
  14. Pierman Walter

    Pierman Walter Chunk Monster Veteran

    Messages:
    249
    Likes Received:
    227
    First Language:
    English
    Primarily Uses:
    N/A
    Something that always bothered me is how easily the player would be able to get past the obstacle if they did something that made sense. If I am a half-demon knight, and the gate is being guarded by a couple of dogs, I am fairly certain I can get past them. If I am wearing so much flame-shielding gear that I am literally fireproof, but I still can't walk over a lit stove, then something has gone wrong. I always have issues with making routes that the my characters are unwilling or unable to cross, too. In my game, a path is closed off because you recognize the corpse of a friend lying in it and are too scared to pass. For a while, this made sense, but then I accidentally figured out that it was possible to take a nap in a mass grave, something so darkly hilarious I had to include it in the actual map. Because of this, the roadblock doesn't make any sense. A person who sleeps on hundreds of dead bodies like it ain't no thang probably isn't going to worry about one of them. I changed it to some landmines instead.
     
    #34
  15. Oddball

    Oddball Veteran Veteran

    Messages:
    1,176
    Likes Received:
    210
    First Language:
    English
    This is a very interesting idea. Not sure how practical it is, but i would love to see that in a game
     
    #35

Share This Page