Oh, goodness, I’ve been looking for someone to give me some good critique on my writing for a while! So first of all, Solistra, let me just say thanks for taking the time to write all that out for me.
Thank you for taking the time to read my comments and actually consider them. I can't even tell you how many times I've given someone extensive advice and had them carelessly brush it off, so it's refreshing to see someone who's actually interested in knowing how they can improve. So thank you, too, for actually being open to it and showing the desire to better your writing (which, by the way, isn't bad at all to begin with).
You’re second point is something I admittedly struggle with. Most things I write tend to either be more telling or a carbon copy of your detailed example (maybe a tiny bit less exaggerated, but still close). I’m still trying to find a happy medium.
The way you wrote in the protagonist's emotions was pretty much exactly what I would go for when describing events, too. In essence, this is how I would do it: instead of telling the reader that something happened, describe
how it happened instead. Don't say that the protagonist was dragged into the water by demons, write the
action of the demons grabbing him.
I can't tell if I'm getting this point across clearly or not, so if you need me to explain, just let me know.
Even as I’m writing this, I’m thinking that it’s almost essential that I do give Morèkar some kind of character quirk, since besides the prologue and a very brief moment at the end of the story, he’s basically a different character, so he needs to make an impression.
Or even just give him something that lets him move or guide the events in some way, or his own thought and commentary about what's happening. There are innumerable ways to insert characterization into a story like this, and the story overall will benefit greatly. Play around with some things and see what you think works best. As it is, Morèkar is basically just a meaningless pawn for what's happening around him instead of a character that's actually immersed in the situation. Immerse us with him.
As for how he reacts to the situation, it’s also something that I’ve had trouble with… You see, the priests took him in when he was still a baby, and his entire life has pretty much centered around this ritual. So, even though he is afraid of dieing, there’s still a sense of…acceptance, I guess?
In that case, I would rely on the greatest of human emotions to explore in the context of a story: internal conflict, or struggling with yourself. There's a sense of acceptance, but he knows he's going to die, so have him fight with that. In a way, this could make the ending of this segment far more emotional: did he accept that he will die gracefully, or does he struggle with it and realize that this is not what he wanted just moments before he falls? Either way, there's a much greater depth of emotion, and the ending will linger more with the reader -- and the character will reverberate in their minds. Show us his last thoughts and how he fights with them... I know that I, personally, would absolutely love to see that.
I really appreciate you taking the time out of your day to sit here and read through that and give such well-thought out critique. I hope that you’ll hang around my thread and give me yet another wonderful critique on the next piece of writing I post!
Of course, I'd be happy to. I'm interested in seeing what else you've written, too.