jobs vs class's what do you think

Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
50
Reaction score
11
First Language
english
Primarily Uses
RMMV
while this dose sort of contain to my own game, im not really locking it onto it as the fluff in my game calls for job development, though i am looking for thoughts on the matter as I may down play the jobs a little more

So right now I'm working on a multi character game with a good few different jobs all the common one's like novice, thief, mage, swordsman, Hunter, less common one's like dancer, jester, sage, sage knight, samurai and allot more...
Given i am making all my character sprites from scratch including clothing, and changeable fashion sprites, I have alot of work ahead lol, not to mention 176 different races...

Not 100% sure right now if I should lock job change or have it that you can freely change outside of battle, ie jobs most games you can't change, class you can sometimes, for example random online you had the 1 job, but ff10.2 you could change class, with some limits,
I have the concept and story line for my game in a card game format but pc is different, in the card game you reset to level 1 every new game given you keep your gold and items, your job resets also, so you could change it, pc version you don't reset to level 1, but I'm making it that you have to do quests to collect different jobs,

This is were I'm getting confused, the hero, + 2 party members chosen from a max reserve of 9 drafted from gameplay during quests, most of these characters start at level 1 novice also, some may have a job already, so maybe a locked job system would be better given you still have flexibility with character choice,

If I lock the job system, there will be a job tree, were you can progress from say a mage to a wizard then to a grand wizard, or swordsman, shield bearer or knight,

anyway I'm tired going to bed, what do you all think, locked or semi locked jobs or open class change?
 

Milennin

"With a bang and a boom!"
Veteran
Joined
Feb 7, 2013
Messages
2,249
Reaction score
1,343
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
I never liked open classes, I much prefer class trees over it, where characters start out in a set class but can branch out to more advanced versions of their base class.
 

ShadowDragon

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
1,134
Reaction score
365
First Language
Dutch
Primarily Uses
RMMV
some can hahve job/class change which can be nice, but locking it gives the possibility to let the player "replay" the game with a different job/class like most online games. there is always a class that have advantage to some bosses, other has some weakness and so on. but the player have the option to play their favorite class in the end :)
 

AmazingKazuki

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 21, 2015
Messages
95
Reaction score
36
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
My friend said something that makes so much sense to me.

Class is something that is locked and jobs are something you can change. That is what I like, too. Jobs you can change even in the real world, so if you become an Alchemist to Guardsmen to Hunter versus locking in as a Warrior class (even if you have advancements).
 

Chocopyro

Just an intermediate leveled adventurer.
Veteran
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
60
Reaction score
60
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
Well let me just say, you have one hell of an ambitious project there, regardless of which one you choose. As for me, it really depends on what kinda project I'm working on. For characters who are pre-made and strongly entangled in narrative driven stories, I prefer fixed. But for open world games where I'm free to make my own character, I prefer having some options. A single class could suit me just fine though, so long as it has some custom choices I could make to make my rogue different from the other rogue I find my character teaming up with temporarily. Think like Pathfinder RPG or D&D where you can choose specific abilities, archetypes, and stuff like that at incremental levels. I love the options they give you, where you could basically play a cleric of Desna who functions like the makeshift party rogue. (Needless to say, going that far for an RPGM project would be entirely unnecessary.)

Classes just give characters the templates they need to become specialized in certain roles. The amount of flexibility needed in that department really is different for each project, and what that project wants to achieve. Whether they focus on narrative, or mechanics, or strive to marry the two, sometimes a superfluous amount of classes does enrich the game, while in others, it can get redundant having more than three.
 
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
50
Reaction score
11
First Language
english
Primarily Uses
RMMV
Well let me just say, you have one hell of an ambitious project there, regardless of which one you choose. As for me, it really depends on what kinda project I'm working on. For characters who are pre-made and strongly entangled in narrative driven stories, I prefer fixed. But for open world games where I'm free to make my own character, I prefer having some options. A single class could suit me just fine though, so long as it has some custom choices I could make to make my rogue different from the other rogue I find my character teaming up with temporarily. Think like Pathfinder RPG or D&D where you can choose specific abilities, archetypes, and stuff like that at incremental levels. I love the options they give you, where you could basically play a cleric of Desna who functions like the makeshift party rogue. (Needless to say, going that far for an RPGM project would be entirely unnecessary.)

Classes just give characters the templates they need to become specialized in certain roles. The amount of flexibility needed in that department really is different for each project, and what that project wants to achieve. Whether they focus on narrative, or mechanics, or strive to marry the two, sometimes a superfluous amount of classes does enrich the game, while in others, it can get redundant having more than three.
yes, im setting out on a mission though i have never done anything by half's, and adding detail, is specialty of mine as i cant forget, i tend to just keep adding things on lol, though over all, im a artist, so making something fit my view is on a OCD level of perfectionism with me lol

~,~ a few of my friends say that im a real life Sheldon (big bang theory,) though, thinking of my 3 ex's i would say im more like Lenard FYI lol

I get what you mean by some times greater amounts of class's can be redundant, though what I'm trying for is to enrich by making class's that while they have some class's that are not great in battle would help outside as a support roll is merchant or blacksmith, even a cook, loved playing d&d

I never liked open classes, I much prefer class trees over it, where characters start out in a set class but can branch out to more advanced versions of their base class.
depending on the game i like both, though i love character development, being able to take a character that was nothing and make it something, unique, lol given that though allot of people get it totally wrong, thats why i like class trees, though i much rather the customizable class or job trees, that allow you to make your own character the way you want it,

some can hahve job/class change which can be nice, but locking it gives the possibility to let the player "replay" the game with a different job/class like most online games. there is always a class that have advantage to some bosses, other has some weakness and so on. but the player have the option to play their favorite class in the end :)
replay value is a good point, the game that im designing has in a way, limitless replay value, playing a good role, or a bad role, and only being able to change your job early in game, makes the replay value greater then ever,
 

BK-tdm

Manga Maker
Veteran
Joined
Jun 21, 2018
Messages
121
Reaction score
101
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
If "open world" freedom is what you seek then making now jobs or classes but "skills" a player can learn and synergize is the way to go, as this approach makes the placer decide on the way which "class" they want to be (put points in dual wield, alchemy, shadow magic, bam, ninja) add a skill reset option and thats it, make players experiment, mix and match and make their own classes.

If the story is actually not open world but railroaded and every character has its set "role" then locking jobs makes more sense, with your traditional warrior hero, archer guy, mage smart guy and healer girl or any other rpg stock character archetypes.

Also 176 races? you'll need at least 40x Silmarillions to cover that much lore... A little bit "too much" in my book, just my two cents.
 
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
50
Reaction score
11
First Language
english
Primarily Uses
RMMV
If "open world" freedom is what you seek then making now jobs or classes but "skills" a player can learn and synergize is the way to go, as this approach makes the placer decide on the way which "class" they want to be (put points in dual wield, alchemy, shadow magic, bam, ninja) add a skill reset option and thats it, make players experiment, mix and match and make their own classes.

If the story is actually not open world but railroaded and every character has its set "role" then locking jobs makes more sense, with your traditional warrior hero, archer guy, mage smart guy and healer girl or any other rpg stock character archetypes.

Also 176 races? you'll need at least 40x Silmarillions to cover that much lore... A little bit "too much" in my book, just my two cents.
176 race's including monsters, and transcended race's (vampire,zombie,werewolf,) i have the lore hand written for each race i did all this for the card version of the game, given though, the digital is based on it, and has the same characters and story quests, there are going to be allot of difference's, putting that all into digital format will take awhile though lol,
the story line, is basically a choose your own adventure, though getting this right is going to be pretty hard, thats why i feel its more correct to call it a open world,
given with the party base while the main party has the hero locked there are 2 party members, that can be switched out for 7 other alternative characters,
more detail here, if you want to have a read,

given that the player has a large alternative party to choose from, i have been thinking that locking each character onto a job path is the best idea, though the player chooses that job path all permanent party characters start off as a novice, but at the same time i dont like the idea of limiting the player, though replay solves that issue i think, more so if the player goes with a new game + option im thinking about adding in, that will directly connect with the main characters party, though as its a new game, you would start with the next gen, without the starting points limits,

im getting pretty tired now ~,~ so im going to leave this post here, if i missed anything ill add to it tomorrow,
 

Kes

Global Moderators
Global Mod
Joined
Aug 3, 2012
Messages
21,598
Reaction score
10,919
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMVXA
@PrideOfTheForbidion Please remember that Games Mechanic Design is for looking at aspects of gameplay at a more conceptual level. It is not for discussing the particulars of a specific project.
 

kairi_key

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
96
Reaction score
48
First Language
thai
Primarily Uses
I'm not sure I understand what you said, but for me, I think fixed job or having job tree suits me better.

Though, recently, I started to have a liking toward a fixed job that can have multiple function/play style. For example, you can choose whether your healer will be good at healing or buffing, or you can make your healer buff him/herself so well that you can make that healer a second tank. Or, a monk who you can either choose to play more aggressive or defensive, but you can't do both.
 
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
50
Reaction score
11
First Language
english
Primarily Uses
RMMV
I'm not sure I understand what you said, but for me, I think fixed job or having job tree suits me better.

Though, recently, I started to have a liking toward a fixed job that can have multiple function/play style. For example, you can choose whether your healer will be good at healing or buffing, or you can make your healer buff him/herself so well that you can make that healer a second tank. Or, a monk who you can either choose to play more aggressive or defensive, but you can't do both.
that's a interesting idea, makes me think back to Ragnarok online, limitations to a characters skill base would do the same thing though,
@PrideOfTheForbidion Please remember that Games Mechanic Design is for looking at aspects of gameplay at a more conceptual level. It is not for discussing the particulars of a specific project.
sorry if i got a bit off topic, ^^:
i should note though im still working on the idea for the RMMV version of my game, i tend to talk in past tense about it as i have already made a table top card game, that im using the same lore and story from, given there will be differences,
 

HumanNinjaToo

The Cheerful Pessimist
Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
384
Reaction score
108
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
My opinion is that if the game has limited characters, but many job/class options, then the player should be allowed to change their mind. It's not fun to get 5-10 hours in and decide you don't like your party composition, but then the only thing to do is start over.

However, if there are enough characters with unique jobs/classes (something like Suikoden), and I can change them out throughout the game, then I'm okay with their class/job being locked.

I prefer things to be simple, but if you're going to give me a plethora of options then allow me to change my mind as much as I want.
 

atoms

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 31, 2013
Messages
481
Reaction score
286
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
I like either a lot depending on how's it done.

Numbers on Classes
What you have to think about is, the numbers. Let's say you have 25 different class changes between a few characters, that can get complex.

Then, if it's locked classes between a large last let's say even 13-17 party members, that actually still feels simple to me if I can get time between who joins the party to see each character.


For fixed/locked Classes
I prefer multiple characters with single classes that can still vary enough to be used differently, so there is some choice and customisation for the player.

As an example, let's say you can power up a character in healing or magic or a little of both.

If the main character is locked in the party, then I also like the idea of that main character having the most customizable options.

I don't mind how it's done
I.e
1. Skill Trees where l choose which skills to power up carefully.
2. Limit skills are taken into battle with many to choose from.
3. Gain skills easily and then choose upgrades from the skills you gain.
4. The most simple form. Just simple level up, have simple skills but you can still choose what order you use the skills in battle and there is an advantage from using #1 or #2 first if that makes sense. This is actually different but I'm happy enough with that.


For Job Classes
I like the Job Points being limited to something like rewards with Level Up or Boss fights or both, or some crystal event thing gives them, something like this so it's more limited on what skills you can gain.

I don't mind switching between different jobs IF either you can still master certain classes and have enough Job Points for others, OR if you can take back your Job Points and then use them in a different class, or the same class with different skills.

I think I like those setups, I'm not saying something else can't work but this is what I know that for me works well.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Latest Threads

Latest Posts

Latest Profile Posts

There a thread out there that tells us the best way to open an RPG that isn't 'the protag gets out of bed'?
Updated my state Stacker Script on itch.io, github is down for some reason (probs just me).
Wife watching Locke and Key. This show is so bad!! You can't just acclimate to discovering magic or magical worlds in less than 60 seconds.
I think I still prefer RPG Maker over Dreams. Been playing around with it, and the controls are really the biggest flaw for me.

Forum statistics

Threads
94,332
Messages
919,996
Members
124,087
Latest member
OrdinaryOne
Top