Needing an opinion on my idea

[CalebW]

Hello everyone, if I haven't met most of you I am pretty new.

The idea with my game/s that I am building are actually centralized around my book series. {Yes, I'm an author too}

My questions to you are:

Would it be enjoyable for side quests (not required for main storyline) to be unlocked by reading certain parts in the book?

Playing the main story as the pre determined characters to the book, then after beating the story having the option to play again as any character from any of the games in the series. Except with different story, battles, and dialouge. Would that be enjoyable?

Actual space travel to align with the story in the books instead of instant teleportation. (This question is more because some of the battles are actually in space.)

Thank you for any feedback.

 

[Bex]

Imagine Playing Final Fantasy7 or the Witcher3, you finished the Game and than you could replay it with any char you want?
How would that work? Same game but the hero looks different?

Reading your Book in real life to progress ingame? Please No.

Why should there be instant teleportation? In some cases that could be good , while its bad in others.

 

[CalebW]

Thank you for the quick an honest reply. Even though the clues from the book would only be on side quests I did have the fear that it would be a distasteful option lol. So I appreciate the blunt answers

 

[Kes]

'General Discussion' is, as the title suggests, for discussing general themes of game making. It is not for giving feedback on individual, specific projects.

I suggest you post in Ideas and Prototypes. Please read the Rules and Guidelines first to decide if you want to post in the general thread or if you have enough to post a separate thread.

[mod]As this thread doesn't belong here and I cannot move it, I am closing it.[/mod]