You see... it's really the fact that the question has to be asked at all. "Why did you raise it that particular way instead of the super-optimal way everyone else does it?". The only reason to ask such a question is if you're one of those kinds of players.
I don't fault people for wanting to spend all the time and effort in the world to make "super optimal Godmons", but I do not really appreciate that a chunk of those players would see any other form of play as wrong enough to ask why it was done in some "sub optimal" way.
I know how to raise an internet-competitive Pokémon. I choose not to, because I think doing so is the most boring grindfest I've ever encountered. I engage in battles with my friends who don't take the games so seriously and play them just for fun or to test their use of strategy in a fight instead of dedication to optimal stat grinds.
To also be clear, a person is not a "stop having fun" guy simply for enjoying all these optimization grinds and tactics and fights. What makes a person one of those is the attitude that their way is really the only or even the best way to play the games. The attitude that their way to play is better than anyone else's way of playing.
"Torterra has a higher Attack base stat than Special Attack, why would you even consider making it a Special Attacker?" kind of reeks of that mentality. I'm sorry if it wasn't meant that way, but that's exactly what it sounds like. It falls right in line with the whole "raise your mon this way, or it's wrong".
Look, if you guys want to run around and use your optimal builds on your mons, go right ahead. I'm not going to stop you from doing that, nor tell you that it's the wrong way to play the games. I am only going to use the phrase "Stop Having Fun Guys", when I am being told that the way I raise and use my mons is wrong, or suboptimal, and there are inferences made that I'm playing the game or raising my mons wrong. If I want to raise a Golem with a high Special Attack, it shouldn't be a question of "Why? His Attack is far superior!". It should be a nod and smile with an understood condition that I am playing for fun and not competitively. The way I raise my mons is often seen as silly to those who play as Competitively as possible. That's kind of by design.
You see, I work 40 hour weeks. I come home, have just enough time to cook supper and maybe play an hour or two of a game before bedtime. This is, of course, not counting on if I have other chores to do around the house or other obligations to people I know in real life. Basically, what that means is... I have no time for Competitive Play. As such, I decided that it's too much work and too time consuming for the limited time I have to actually play a game. So, playing for fun became my only motivation for playing a video game. I'll leave "being the very best, like no one ever was" to all the kids and such of the world who don't have such taxes on their time. For me, with my limited time, "having fun" in Pokémon basically entails just trying new things, doing unexpected things, and using as many "NU" mons as possible. Everyone else is exploring the other path of the Metagame, so I'll explore the path I will enjoy. The path that is all about experimentation, no rules on builds, sub-optimal stats, and crazy movesets. None of it is designed to withstand super EV trained mons, and I don't pretend it is. What it's designed to do, is to make combat unique and enjoyable between the friends I have who take the same stance on gameplay that I do.
I built my Torterra to take advantage of the fact that most of its moves rely on Special Attack to even work. Is that good or bad? I don't know. I know it works for me, and it doesn't work for competitive play. Though, maybe if it was tweaked right, it may work in competitive play as well. Who knows? I know that most mons only have one or two builds in Competitive Play. Is that because everyone has run every conceivable way to build a mon? Or, it is because a few people figured out "optimal builds" and just distributed that information while everyone else is too afraid to do anything different with their parties or mons? Again, I don't know for sure which of those it is. I suspect it has more to do with option 2 than option 1, but without having played Competitively before, I have no way of knowing. Does any of that make that way of playing wrong? No. It's exciting for those who play the games that way, and that's good enough for me.
For me, the pinnacle of excitement in Pokémon is playing the way I do. Goofing off, exploring, experimenting, not worrying about EVs and Natures, and trying to do something interesting with my mons that most people don't see often. To me, that's fun. Today, I'll make a Special Attacker Torterra, tomorrow I'll make a Lightning Brawler Ditto, and maybe next week I'll breed a shiny Charmander just because I like the Black color of Charizard. Who knows?
I'll play my way, you guys can play yours. Just please, stop trying to tell me or even insinuate that I'm raising my mons wrong. If I want to make a level 100 Metapod who only knows Harden, I should be free to do so without being told my way is "sub optimal" or "wrong". Let me have my fun, you guys can have yours.
Besides, I get far more enjoyment out of Dex completion than I get out of the Battle Mechanics. I like catching them all and seeing them all. Someday, I will have a complete Dex. Maybe this generation I'll get to do so. I hope so, it would be fantastic to do it once in my life.
In any case, this is a fairly long and extensive post. I'm sorry if I irritate, annoy, or offend anyone with it, but it was seriously starting to make my blood boil that people were telling me I was playing wrong because of how I raised my Torterra. So, I'll just skip to more interesting news (or at least I think it's more interesting) and tell you all that I finally completed all of the Super Training stuff with my Braixen. The worst one was that stupid one where if you get hit at all, it resets your score. That one should have been last, holy crap. But, I got the medal on every single one, I even got a Dusk Stone, a Sun Stone, and a Fire Stone out of it! I kind of wish I had gotten a Ribbon on my Braixen for the hard work I put in. Oh well, I guess. Maybe there's one for maxing out the friendship on the Pokémon Amie section? 3 Hearts on that for Braixen! Maybe I'll even get past Route 8 tonight and get to my second Gym.
Is it just me, or does this game world seem a LOT smaller than previous titles?