Avery: I sometimes feel redundant when saying this, but the icons are really awesome. I really like the moon variants. The witch hat is also amazing. I like the design a lot more than the RTP witch icons, so I think I’m going to switch those from now on. Those lantern pumpkins are love. You did a great job on making the whole pumpkin seem enlightened. The big pumpkin house is really nicely done and a great addition to Pandamaru’s pumpkin houses. I also feel you’ve improved a lot doing Ace RTP stuff, so great job
Banquo: I don’t have the POP! Set yet, so I can’t say too much about those contributions, except that’s it’s really nice you added several skintones. I am really loving the antique DS tiles though. It really makes me wish we had more of these. (Maybe something for future contributions?) I’m not too sure about the pirate tiles though. Don’t get me wrong they look nice, but they don’t seem to be DS styled? I don’t know if it’s because of a different colour scheme or because of the different way of shading (on the chest).
Candacis: The attic tilesheet is really well done. I really like the dolls you made. They’re both based on the RTP children right? We could make something really creepy out of those. A box animation like the chest animation you made would have been a nice add-on. Thanks for the sample btw
Caz: More DS stuff! Yay.

DS portraits are quite limited in comparison to other, so Ralph’s addition to them is really nice. The tiles are a nice add-on for anyone looking for something creepy. I like that you added their normal look as well, so you can make your game go from normal creepy to horror.
Chaos Avian: Really love the cartoonesque battlers. Love all of them, especially the Jacks and Gloomwood. I also really love your colour schemes. Great job all around.
Hiddenone: Quite some scary sprites plus those lovely deers. Those are my favourite from your submission this time. The grazing behaviours are really great as well.
Ksjp17: Thanks for the demo and setting the animations up in the database. That's going to save people a lot of work. The animations look really good. My favourite one is Ground Fire, because at the very end it kind of forms a face.
Nanokan: Nice worldmap add-ons, but to be honest I'm not really seeing the slime part on most of them.
Palladinthug: Nice POP! Stuff. I find the smaller the object, the harder it is to draw it right and recognizable, but you did a very good job with these. Iggy is adorable by the way.
PandaMaru: Those amazing pumpkin houses <3 They’re all looking really good, but I do like the ones (4 and 7) with lots of decoration. Also a big thank you for including even more pumpkins in this very thread. I guess the only thing is missing is some pumpkin furniture for their indoor. (Perhaps an idea for next time?

)
Skeezixs1: Ooh, game over screens and such. That’s not something we see very often. I do like the bases and the blood back one. The portraits/openings are really lovely as well. Kudos to your artist.
Super121830: Rainbow chests. Always handy to have. Side views/back views would have been nice as well though
Thalzon: Great battlers as always. The skeleton’s my favourite and that spider scares the hell out of me. (I do hope you’ll be using some of the concepts you’ve drawn later. There was some great stuff in there.)
Valkyriet: Amazing geishas (and shamisen)! I’d love to see a walking sprite of her. (I’m kinda curious, the credits mention GaiaOnline... was it your reference or?)