Unpopular Opinions: The Thread

[The Stranger]

@trouble time Wall-E's great! Up is perhaps my favourite. Well, the opening part that shows the life of the old man is.

 

[standardplayer]

@The Stranger Rick Astley is apparently such a huge fan of the movie 'Up' that he refuses to let anyone even hold his copy, let alone borrow it.

 

[The Stranger]

@standardplayer I guess he's just never going to give it up, never going to let it down, never going to turn around and desert it.

 

[mlogan]

Up is one of my all time favorites.

@The Stranger I would have been disappointed if you hadn’t.

 

[Former_Sky]

The Bruce Faulconer soundtrack for Dragonball Z is way better than the original japanese music. I also prefer the Ocean dub of the first 60 some episodes, mostly because that's how I first got introduced to the series.

 

[Mystic_Enigma]

On that note relating to the above, I prefer dubs over Japenese audio when it comes to shows. I find the latter overrated and people are too quick to judge the former.

I mean really, I would rather watch a "poor" version of something I can understand than the "perfect", incomprehensible original!

 

[slimmmeiske2]

The reason I prefer subs to dubs doesn't have anything to do with the voice acting, but with censoring, especially when it comes to characters, relationships and storylines.

Not sure if this is still an ongoing thing currently, but the anime I watched as a kid had a lot of stuff removed/changed.

And as someone who's not a native English speaker, if I would only start watching dubs, I might as well stop watching 99% of the time

 

[Former_Sky]

For what it's worth, dubs haven't typically cut stuff since the mid 2000's. Every anime is very faithful to the original these days.

 

[Kupotepo]

I prefer dubs over subs and like to be a contrarian in order to make people see both sides. So bare with my wishy-washy [impartial] way. The language and cultural barrier is not censorship. I agree with @Former_Sky the cold war ended and the translation is direct as possible to the original language. Some cultures prefer to express emotion directly and while other cultures prefer to express subtle emotions. Some words did not exist in another language, so the translators tried their best to explain or choose words similar to the original words. The culture subtlety is really difficult to pick up unless people live there.

@slimmmeiske2, I also see your point about censorship, but I think it is relating to the public decency laws. I think both subs and dubs get scrutinize both.

Spoiler: Other people views

5 Reasons Anime Subs are Better than Dubs

Dattebayo!

www.inverse.com

Is subbed anime better than dubbed anime, or vice versa? Why? - Quora

 

[KakonComp]

An unpopular opinion, and relevant to the current conversation, is I don't like overly dramatic theatrical voices, which means I'm not really into either Sub or Dub, since animation tends to have very...animated voices.

in this case I only prefer Sub for the reasons @slimmmeiske2 mentioned, plus I tend to focus on the words more than how they're said if I'm reading them.

I'm always on the lookout for RPGs that let me read over listen.

 

[slimmmeiske2]

I just can't imagine my life without subs I picked up English a lot faster, because of them. I learned small bits of Japanese culture and language by watching subs, which then let me to study Japanese and even study in Japan for a year.

I guess it's also just a cultural thing. Here in Belgium the only shows and films that get dubbed are kids shows/films. We expect anyone who isn't a kid to be able to read fast enough to follow the subtitles.

 

[Touchfuzzy]

My thoughts on dubs vs subs: Some shows have remarkably good dubs. In other cases, I'll stick to the sub.

The style of voice acting done in JP sounds absolutely ridiculous to me when done in English. It's very overdramatic, and I'm used to hearing it from JP voice actors, but if I hear someone do the exact same thing in English, it feels really awkward. It isn't because of SKILL, it is because I expect English spoken word to be much more subdued.

So usually, the times I like the dub are when I feel like the show itself was subdued enough to allow an English cast to speak English in a way that I find natural.

(And with most nonanimated stuff, I can't stand dubs because the fact that the mouth movements don't match the spoken word is way more breaking for my enjoyment than having to read. I also do have a remarkably high reading speed though.)

 

[trouble time]

For what it's worth, dubs haven't typically cut stuff since the mid 2000's. Every anime is very faithful to the original these days.

Actually its less censoring now and more inserting political ideas where there were none, at least woth funimation.

 

[Woland]

My unpopular opinion: this thread is full of really sad people.

 

[Kupotepo]

@Woland, I am not sad. I am easily nervous and excited. I mean feel sad when people die are natural. Feeling sad when seeing other people are struggle is natural.
I think the thread is about people who want to improve themselves by rant in here, so others do not have to hear it.

 

[orochii]

Best dubs are the bad dubs or intentionally funny dubs.

See DBZ's Big Green, Ghost Stories official english dub, some abridged versions of popular anime (YuGiOh, Pokemon, DBZ), and some bad stinky dubbed hentais.

 

[KakonComp]

I can get behind a totally new story behind a dub, assuming people know beforehand the original is vastly different.

 

[trouble time]

My unpopular opinion: this thread is full of really sad people.

I dont think thats unpopular

 

[Oddball]

I think with a few minor tweaks, the phantom menace could have been a decent movie

The only cannon star wars movies were the ones made by george lucas

 

[Redeye]

I vastly prefer the SW prequel trilogy over the originals. Revenge of the Sith specifically is an amazing tragedy.

People who blindly slander the prequels are fun-hating losers.