Unpopular Opinions: The Thread

Kato-A

Artist and developer
Veteran
Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Messages
221
Reaction score
481
First Language
Spanish
Primarily Uses
RMMV
Unpopular opinion: Random encounters is bad game design.
Even worse when they happen every few steps. I prefer to see the monsters on the map and decide if I want to fight.
Unpopular opinion 2: The default fighting system gets boring very quickly. Unless the developer has put some effort into it, I skip games that have fighting.
Unpopular opinion 3: No all protagonists need to save the world.
 
Last edited:

kirbwarrior

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
Nov 13, 2014
Messages
1,242
Reaction score
1,130
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
N/A
Perhaps we have a different concept of "charge attack".
I was specifically going off of what Kes said, where you 'charge' one attack and deal double the damage next turn, which in turn amounts to two attacks worth of damage.

You apply a status effect to increase your damage dealt in the next turn, then use it with whatever skill in the next turn. You can waste it on a normal attack if you want to.
See, this is a great way to have a charging ability. Mind, it's hard to make it a 'choice' unless the skill has a different resource cost than the given skill. If it costs less, charge+high damage skill is always best, if it costs more then it's not worth it. Now if it is something like a character gimmick they bring into any class, then that's fine and awesome. Or an accessory that lets you Charge at no cost.

I like the concept of a charge attack.
Same. It was merely that one form of implementation that seemed bad.


Has anyone brought up durability yet? At this point it doesn't even conceptually seem like a good idea to me anymore. I still enjoy Fire Emblem, but it definitely is not part of why.

Video games don't need to be 'fun' to be 'entertaining', but you definitely aren't going to have a homerun popular game if you make that game.

EDIT: I don't think reality/"realistic" should ever be used to try and 'justify' bad game design, boring character designs or personalities, or unenjoyablee gameplay.
 
Last edited:

M.I.A.

Goofball Extraordinaire
Veteran
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
1,074
Reaction score
930
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
Ohh, I have one!

I love it when games make it possible to break them.

I always feel like a genius when I discover some cheesy tactics or unintended mechanics in games :p

Even just unbalanced games sometimes, but its more fun if its something I discover as opposed to hearing about it beforehand ofc.
This is what I LOOOVE about Final Fantasy Tactics and Bravely Default series. You can do some insane stuff. :)
-MIA
 

kirbwarrior

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
Nov 13, 2014
Messages
1,242
Reaction score
1,130
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
N/A
I love it when games make it possible to break them.
On a lesser note, I don't think games need to ever be perfectly balanced. It's fine if there is an optimal choice as long as all the others aren't trap choices. I can understand the need in competitive multiplayer games, but even co-op multiplayer games don't need it, that's just a problem of people overvaluing optimization at the cost of fun.

On a greater note, I love glitches so much. I intentionally don't update my games unless necessary. I replay Pokemon Blue for the insanity of it. I understand developers wanting to get rid of glitches that can easily break the game (in the literal sense), but even Link's Awakening's Screen Jumping is fantastic and that skirts the line for how easy it is to pull off just by accident.
 

Andrew-Burcastro

Villager
Member
Joined
May 6, 2021
Messages
20
Reaction score
12
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMZ
Humanity should have gotten tried of the musical genre in Ancient Greek times.
 

Tai_MT

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
6,068
Reaction score
5,847
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
Unpopular Opinion:

Everyone likes to say they listen, but in practice almost nobody does. This tends to make most people not really worth interacting with as the only reason they'd ever listen to you is for a few reasons:

1. To say "me too!" so that they can now talk about themselves or feel included in a conversation.

2. Looking for things to reply to. "Jumping in points". This approaches "the worst of human behavior" when the person is looking for those things to reply for purely malicious reasons (continue an argument, tear someone down, shift goal posts, dominate a conversation, one up someone else, etcetera).

3. A means to pretend to be a good person. As in, to deliver fake sympathy or empathy. Or, just to appear like they care about a person and what that person says/thinks/feels.
---
Put simply, few people actually listen in order to engage in an actual conversation with someone. A lot of it is done just so that they have places to dump their own opinions, ideas, points of view, etcetera.

You don't see a lot of people who ask questions in a conversation. Who try to dig deeper into whatever someone else is saying. As a result, few people actually have "conversational skills" and as a result, a large chunk of the populace feels lonely, unheard, and un-cared for.

The amount of people who have started treated me like the greatest person ever in their lives from just listening to what they have to say and asking questions about the things they talk about is very depressing to me. It's like, "Have you really been through all of your life so far and NOBODY has taken a baseline interest in who you are and what you like?".

Let's face it, it's sad when several women I've dated said that I was "the best they ever had" just because "You actually cared about me and what I thought.". I am not a catch and when the only thing I have "ups" on over any other guy is "I actually listened and asked questions", it makes me feel pretty bad for those people.

Another unpopular opinion:

People spend too much time on their cellphones and on social media. Cellphones have rapidly dwindled most people's patience and attention spans with all the "instant gratification" such devices bring at any particular moment. This means that any time they have to work for a dopamine hit, it's instantly seen as "not worth the time" or "someone is a terrible person for not giving me a dopamine hit". Ever get upset that someone read a text you wrote, but never replied? Yeah, that's you being a terrible person. That's your getting upset that someone didn't give you your Drugs when you wanted them. Ever get upset at the length of a video, a post, a comment, or something else that is "completely optional" for you to interact with? Yeah, that's you being a terrible person. You're upset that you don't have the patience for something and that other person should cater to you, specifically, because of your lack of patience (a character flaw). If you've been listening so far, you know there's a difference between "it's long and optional" and "it's long, but not optional". Like an intro to a game you can't skip isn't optional. But, deciding to click into a video that is 30 minutes long and getting upset by it... or deciding to read a long post and getting upset by it... Yeah, that's different. Anyone who wasn't listening, will try to argue against this, by raising this particular point and trying to force a "distinction" between the two things. Or, rather, trying to make the two things exactly the same, in order to point out how bad "length" of anything is.

Social media, on the other hand, has rendered most people socially inept and impotent. Social anxiety is at an all-time high these days, and it's probably not a coincidence that the rise of this issue within people started with the invention and mass utilization of Social Media platforms. Places where you can pretend to interact with people to not "feel alone" anymore. Or, places to ignore that you are so very lonely. Social Media has also created very insular pockets of people who never have to consider viewpoints other than their own, thus, have no ability to deal with criticism or even complaints against them. Every perceived slight tends to turn into "you are the worst person on the planet for making me feel bad!" type affairs. Likewise, this has also contributed to people always having "the need to be right", rather than "innate curiousity". It makes them defend everything they say and do, even when it becomes obvious they're wrong or have no way to refute the arguments or opinions levied against them. This is because Social Media, inherently, is about "chasing clout". Or, rather, crafting this "other self" for people to view and worship and respect, that isn't you. It's about LARPing as a personality you perceive as "better" than the one you were born with. Any challenge to that persona is then seen as "a personal attack", even if the only challenge is "hey, you're wrong in this one instance" or "Hey, that really isn't a nice thing to say". Social Media promotes combativeness and lonliness rather than curiousity, humbleness, and comraderie. It has also lead to people believing that most "online friends" are actually "real friends". If you want to find out who your real friends are, you ask them to give you (not lend!) $2,000 and to help you move into a new place. People who do both are your actual friends. If there isn't a person on the planet you would do that for, then you don't consider anyone else your friend either. Social media perpetuates the illusion that "just interacting with someone regularly, means they're your friend". This is something most people figure out is "not true" in High School when people you used to hang out with start treating you like crap because you actually had flaws you never worked on as a person. They figure it out when they lose friends and have to make new ones.
---
There we go, two more unpopular opinions of mine.
 

Willibab

The Lord of Whackery
Veteran
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
677
Reaction score
1,790
First Language
Norwegian
Primarily Uses
RMMZ
I don't like reading. If it wasn't for audiobooks I wouldn't have read a single book past the age of 12 xD
 

Tai_MT

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
6,068
Reaction score
5,847
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
@Willibab

That's actually a very popular opinion. The unpopular opinion at this point is enjoying reading.
 

Avery

Sleeping Dinosaur
Restaff
Joined
Oct 13, 2012
Messages
3,493
Reaction score
22,906
First Language
German
Primarily Uses
N/A
Unpopular Opinion:

Everyone likes to say they listen, but in practice almost nobody does. This tends to make most people not really worth interacting with as the only reason they'd ever listen to you is for a few reasons:

1. To say "me too!" so that they can now talk about themselves or feel included in a conversation.

2. Looking for things to reply to. "Jumping in points". This approaches "the worst of human behavior" when the person is looking for those things to reply for purely malicious reasons (continue an argument, tear someone down, shift goal posts, dominate a conversation, one up someone else, etcetera).

3. A means to pretend to be a good person. As in, to deliver fake sympathy or empathy. Or, just to appear like they care about a person and what that person says/thinks/feels.
---
Put simply, few people actually listen in order to engage in an actual conversation with someone. A lot of it is done just so that they have places to dump their own opinions, ideas, points of view, etcetera.

You don't see a lot of people who ask questions in a conversation. Who try to dig deeper into whatever someone else is saying. As a result, few people actually have "conversational skills" and as a result, a large chunk of the populace feels lonely, unheard, and un-cared for.

The amount of people who have started treated me like the greatest person ever in their lives from just listening to what they have to say and asking questions about the things they talk about is very depressing to me. It's like, "Have you really been through all of your life so far and NOBODY has taken a baseline interest in who you are and what you like?".

Let's face it, it's sad when several women I've dated said that I was "the best they ever had" just because "You actually cared about me and what I thought.". I am not a catch and when the only thing I have "ups" on over any other guy is "I actually listened and asked questions", it makes me feel pretty bad for those people.

Another unpopular opinion:

People spend too much time on their cellphones and on social media. Cellphones have rapidly dwindled most people's patience and attention spans with all the "instant gratification" such devices bring at any particular moment. This means that any time they have to work for a dopamine hit, it's instantly seen as "not worth the time" or "someone is a terrible person for not giving me a dopamine hit". Ever get upset that someone read a text you wrote, but never replied? Yeah, that's you being a terrible person. That's your getting upset that someone didn't give you your Drugs when you wanted them. Ever get upset at the length of a video, a post, a comment, or something else that is "completely optional" for you to interact with? Yeah, that's you being a terrible person. You're upset that you don't have the patience for something and that other person should cater to you, specifically, because of your lack of patience (a character flaw). If you've been listening so far, you know there's a difference between "it's long and optional" and "it's long, but not optional". Like an intro to a game you can't skip isn't optional. But, deciding to click into a video that is 30 minutes long and getting upset by it... or deciding to read a long post and getting upset by it... Yeah, that's different. Anyone who wasn't listening, will try to argue against this, by raising this particular point and trying to force a "distinction" between the two things. Or, rather, trying to make the two things exactly the same, in order to point out how bad "length" of anything is.

Social media, on the other hand, has rendered most people socially inept and impotent. Social anxiety is at an all-time high these days, and it's probably not a coincidence that the rise of this issue within people started with the invention and mass utilization of Social Media platforms. Places where you can pretend to interact with people to not "feel alone" anymore. Or, places to ignore that you are so very lonely. Social Media has also created very insular pockets of people who never have to consider viewpoints other than their own, thus, have no ability to deal with criticism or even complaints against them. Every perceived slight tends to turn into "you are the worst person on the planet for making me feel bad!" type affairs. Likewise, this has also contributed to people always having "the need to be right", rather than "innate curiousity". It makes them defend everything they say and do, even when it becomes obvious they're wrong or have no way to refute the arguments or opinions levied against them. This is because Social Media, inherently, is about "chasing clout". Or, rather, crafting this "other self" for people to view and worship and respect, that isn't you. It's about LARPing as a personality you perceive as "better" than the one you were born with. Any challenge to that persona is then seen as "a personal attack", even if the only challenge is "hey, you're wrong in this one instance" or "Hey, that really isn't a nice thing to say". Social Media promotes combativeness and lonliness rather than curiousity, humbleness, and comraderie. It has also lead to people believing that most "online friends" are actually "real friends". If you want to find out who your real friends are, you ask them to give you (not lend!) $2,000 and to help you move into a new place. People who do both are your actual friends. If there isn't a person on the planet you would do that for, then you don't consider anyone else your friend either. Social media perpetuates the illusion that "just interacting with someone regularly, means they're your friend". This is something most people figure out is "not true" in High School when people you used to hang out with start treating you like crap because you actually had flaws you never worked on as a person. They figure it out when they lose friends and have to make new ones.
---
There we go, two more unpopular opinions of mine.
My unpopular opinion here: tl, dr
 

TheoAllen

Self-proclaimed jack of all trades
Veteran
Joined
Mar 16, 2012
Messages
7,335
Reaction score
11,084
First Language
Indonesian
Primarily Uses
N/A
My unpopular opinion here: tl, dr
It funny how this instantly proven
This means that any time they have to work for a dopamine hit, it's instantly seen as "not worth the time" or "someone is a terrible person for not giving me a dopamine hit".


There we go, two more unpopular opinions of mine.
Not really two, just one. With the tldr in your first post. Just pointing this out :p

Cellphones are the worst invention in the world.


----
I'll add one.
Throwing unprompted opinions is not cool. No one asks yours. Unless you are actively being 'harassed' or in a discussion to bring an interesting point of view. For example, you don't go say how you don't like gacha games just because it is popular among your friends unless your friends trying to make you play gacha games
 

Tai_MT

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
6,068
Reaction score
5,847
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
It funny how this instantly proven




Not really two, just one. With the tldr in your first post. Just pointing this out :p




----

Yeah, probably right. I might consider them two separate opinions, but you could very easily lump them into the same thing.

Heck, I'd forgotten that I'd even posted that in the original comment. Thanks for pointing it out!

I'll add one.
Throwing unprompted opinions is not cool. No one asks yours. Unless you are actively being 'harassed' or in a discussion to bring an interesting point of view. For example, you don't go say how you don't like gacha games just because it is popular among your friends unless your friends trying to make you play gacha games

I'm having a hard time deciding if this is aimed at me in particular, or if it's just a general thing. I'll assume it's a general thing.
 

TheoAllen

Self-proclaimed jack of all trades
Veteran
Joined
Mar 16, 2012
Messages
7,335
Reaction score
11,084
First Language
Indonesian
Primarily Uses
N/A
I'm having a hard time deciding if this is aimed at me in particular, or if it's just a general thing. I'll assume it's a general thing.
It's a general thing. If anything, it was aimed at me for like 2 years ago. Looking at me back then, it was just a stupid thing to do. Nowadays, I just try to shut up.
 

Tai_MT

Veteran
Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
6,068
Reaction score
5,847
First Language
English
Primarily Uses
RMMV
It's a general thing. If anything, it was aimed at me for like 2 years ago. Looking at me back then, it was just a stupid thing to do. Nowadays, I just try to shut up.

I honestly can't imagine you being that type of person. You certainly don't portray that here on the forums. Which, honestly, speaks volumes about how far you've come as a person if that used to be how you were.

In either case, even if it is an "Unpopular Opinion", I think it's pretty valuable advice for almost anyone.

I'll take it on board, even if it wasn't meant for me. It certainly couldn't hurt, after all.
 

A_Higher_Plane

Spiritual person, self-improvement geek, Game Dev
Veteran
Joined
Oct 3, 2015
Messages
707
Reaction score
198
First Language
Russian
Primarily Uses
RMMV
My unpopular opinion: They should work hard and release one excellent 3D RPG Maker. You can make turn-based and real-time RPG Maker games on it and RPG games like Kingdom Hearts, MMORPGs like FF14, hybrid games like FF7R, and turn-based games like FFX.
 

TheoAllen

Self-proclaimed jack of all trades
Veteran
Joined
Mar 16, 2012
Messages
7,335
Reaction score
11,084
First Language
Indonesian
Primarily Uses
N/A
Perhaps that is what RPG Maker Unite is for.
 

Latest Threads

Latest Posts

Latest Profile Posts

This could probably be an entire thread, but it’s really interesting how replaying a game several years later can change how you relate to a character. I think Tidus from FFX got such a bad rap. I getchu. Completely different reaction as an adult now.
As you see, I still enjoy writing tutorials. Is there anything specific you want to see? (I know mapping and editing/resource making is usually popular, but those are very broad topics)
Well, I wanted to expand player battlers visually and now have 3 sheets and counting for each of my players party.
1. Regular sheet
2. The character has turned stone sheet.
3. Using potions sheet.

Technically the main hero has 4 since he starts with a wooden sword, and I felt that the battler should reflect that until he gets a metal one.

Right back to the RM game dev grind in about 15 minutes. :LZSexcite:
Days ago I gave someone the sage advice not to steer away from your main project or take up another one to abandon the first. After figuring a way that would save me years of development, I am forced to redo a lot of stuff on my own turf, near to remake half of what I have already made.
Somewhere down the line I must have crossed paths with bad karma.
:kaomad2:

Forum statistics

Threads
131,733
Messages
1,222,756
Members
173,484
Latest member
sewamobilbali
Top