Sorry, I was very busy lately so it took me some time to write it again.
I really liked the game, and I can't wait to see the final result.
Graphics :
I think the graphics are one of the best thing in your game : There is a lot of animations, artworks, busts, light effects, custscenes, custom title screen and menu, a 3D view and a lot of maps are parallaxed... When you play the game, you don't really notice there is still some RTP, so it look quite professional. Moreover the graphics, are creating a really dark and scary atmosphere, making the game very immersive. Though, Sometime, you can't see anything at all because the screen is too dark and it's hard to play when you can't see anything.
Musics :
The musics are really great and creates a good atmosphere too. They fit your game very well.
Story :
I liked the story as well, and the dialogues are well written but I think it could be even better, with for example more original and complex characters to make it even more interesting and surprising.
Mapping :
The mapping is really awesome, especially the parallaxes, even if there is problems you will need to correct on some maps. Though, be carefull with light effects and parallaxes, it slow the game, and sometimes, they are not necessary. My computeur is really slow, and it was sometime a pain to play with thees lags.
Eventing :
The cutscenes, menus and the title screen are working fine, good job.
Puzzles:
It's the part I disliked the most in your game. They are way too difficult and painfull too solve. For most of them I had to read your walktrough to solve them. That's not normal. I souldn't have to stop playing and open my browser to solve a puzzle. This completely break the atmosphere.
( By the way, here is a great tutorial about puzzles :
http://blog.rpgmakerweb.com/tutorials/how-to-design-a-good-puzzle/ )
Even if almost all the puzzles themselves in your game are bad designed, the eventing is very great, though.
Overall, It's really a good job you did here, but it's not perfect and I hope you will improve it. Good luck !
