Sigh~Ok.I can see its going to be one of "THOSE"topics.

I thought exactly the same thing last night when I read this, and there was only the original post in the thread.
Here's the thing, NYX: YOU know exactly what you want. In your mind, you can see it as clear as day. NOBODY else is in that position. If you expect to get exactly what you need, then you need to go into GREAT detail about it - you need to paint a word picture so others can "see" the same thing you do. Using a few choice keywords is not going to get the right message across. You might expect that an artist SHOULD be able to read your original request and make your sprites, but it doesn't work that way. I'm not an artist, and I already have half a dozen questions that NEED to be answered if you're going to get the sprites you want. It WILL take effort on your part to make sure you provide ALL the needed information, but it takes more effort on the part of an artist to create it, and they don't want to have to do it over and over because you let them make assumptions rather than providing the detail, and they got it wrong. And YOU don't want to have them do it over and over either.
Let's look at your original request:
items blown by the wind
- is it a sheet of paper, a pile of papers, leaves, or sand? What? It's your game, not theirs, so YOU need to decide this.
- is it inside or outside? Where is the breeze coming from? Should they start on the ground, or higher up?
- are they scattered on the ground initially, or are they in a pile? How big is the pile? How many items are scattered?
- is it a BIG gust of wind (will it lift them high into the air) or a breeze that gently moves them from one place to another?
- a box that falls or tumbles is nothing like something light that blows in the wind.
- you will need one sprite for their starting position, another sprite for their ending position, and the sprites for the animations?
broken box
- is the box on the floor, on a table or bench, or up high?
- HOW do the items fall? Do they spill out and fall straight down? How far? Do they fall to the base of the box then roll away from the box? How far?
- what are they - apples, tomatoes, potatoes? Again, YOU need to decide this.
- do you need the actual animation of them falling/rolling, or do you just need the before and after sprites?
Maybe if you explain the events around these animations, it might help. Where are they before, and in what state? What is it that causes the box to break and the items to fall out? All that sort of stuff provides extra detail that the artist WILL need to come up with something close to what you're after. Otherwise, you're just going to get sprite after sprite that isn't what you want, and nobody will be happy.
Now, I would like to point out some things that I would strongly suggest you do, whenever you make requests for sprites. This will prevent all of your requests degenerating into threads that end up with a lot of people being insulted and being locked without your request fulfilled.
- show respect to people who are helping you. If they ask you for clarification, it's not because they're stupid or they're being mean - it's because they WANT to do the sprite for you, but there are gaps in their understanding. Look to see how many ways your request could be interpreted, or ask them for their understanding, to see where you need to provide clarification. If they come across as a bit impatient or even rude, don't turn it into a slanging match. THEY are doing something for YOU. YOU are the one who needs to be more polite.
- show respect for the time they are willing to spend. Don't expect them to do it over and over and over until they get it right. Be prepared to put in more work yourself explaining things at the start, to avoid the need for revisions.
- "Dont ask about payment for custome sprites.All poasts about being payed will be ignored so dont bother." This is just darn rude. Sprites are not easy, or fast to make. What you are saying here is "I expect you to bend over backwards for me making this, but you should not expect anything in return. The time and effort you put into this means absolutely nothing to me." You are telling people you do not value their time, and then as the thread goes on, you continue to be rude to them. WHY would anyone WANT to create a sprite for you, when you are just rude to them all the time? It's okay to ask for something for free, but don't come in saying you don't value their time and you don't believe they deserve anything in return. Even if I WOULD do something for free, reading that sentence would make me turn around and look for another request to work on, from someone who appreciates others who do things for them. Personally, I would NEVER ask someone to make something for me, without offering payment in return. I value people who are willing to spend their time doing something to help me.
- for goodness sake, use a spell checker! I normally don't gripe about this, but your spelling is really, REALLY bad! I'm not being mean, and I don't mean to offend you, but bad spelling and grammar are CONTRIBUTING to the confusion. It takes seconds to run a spell checker over your post. Once more, it's a little way of showing respect to the people who are considering working on your request - one more thing you can do to make it easier for them to understand what you want.
Now you could ignore all of the above and get defensive (or
offensive) about it, or you could consider that I've probably had one or two people make game assets for me in the past and I
might know what I'm talking about. Up to you
